The noble macaw is a wonderful parrot companion. They are very difficult to find though. My first noble macaw Mihijo I got in 1995. The pair that had him only produced that one clutch. Julio was a rescue that we adopted. Although he has some of the wonderful Noble macaw traits I love his abusive past hinders him in some ways. I also think no other bird even a noble macaw can ever be like my Mihijo was. He was very well socialized, was the only bird for several years and I spend a LOT of time training him to do tricks, even tricks that were not natural to parrots. Mihijo loved people and anyone could handle him.
I had another mini macaw named Diego. He was co-parented Illiger's macaw. He was well bred and because he was co parented he had some wild traits to him that made him pure macaw. I loved Diego and really enjoyed him. In some ways I think he prepared me for my RFM Valentino who is the most challenging parrot I ever lived with.
If I didn't already have Julio and was looking into a second parrot I narrowed my choice to a Panama amazon. Due to the research, what owners and breeders say about this species and with what I would like in my flock this is the best parrot for me. I thought about a yellow collar macaw but in reality this would be a smaller Valentino and I wanted more of a balance in my flock.
In my opinion and experience to have a BTM AND a RFM would of drove me INSANE. I am the main caretaker and who the parrots always bond too. To have two parrots with the somewhat same traits and challenges would be too much for me. I came really really close to getting a BTM when Valentino was a baby. For me getting the BTM would of been too much to handle.
I noticed you are in MPLS. I am in Oakdale. Over the years I have noticed the bird community with quality breeders are mostly gone. I find myself out of touch with our bird community and ended up getting my Valentino from one of the best macaw breeders in Texas. I would love to know where Piper came from as I would not be surprised if he came from the same breeder.